Menu

Approval

What is waiting for approval, what blocks each one, and who may give it.

Demonstration project - no figure here describes a real facilityChanges are not saved
Why

Every refusal is checked in the page, again in the write service, and again by a database constraint.

Writes are validated against the engineering rules and then refused, because no database has been configured for this environment.

Awaiting approval

3

Approvable now

1

Blocked

2

Approvals recorded

2

The author may not approve their own work

Every other rule on this page stops a specific mistake. This one exists because approval is the point at which somebody becomes answerable for a document, and a signature on your own work is not an attestation.

Awaiting approval

Deliverables awaiting approval
DeliverableTitleAuthorCheckerApproverWhat blocks it
ZRF-CMP-0007Commissioning Procedure - Cooling Water System 31J. NovakS. Lindqvistnone assigned
  • open gap: Commissioning sequence: the system boundary for SYS-31-01 is in dispute
  • open blocking comment: The system boundary for SYS-31-01 is taken from the drawn boundary on ZRF-PID-3101. The commissioning breakdown disagrees about HV-3101.
ZRF-HTP-0015Hydrotest Procedure - Condensate Export System 12A. RahmanN. Okonkwonone assigned
  • open gap: Approved test pressure basis: the design pressure of P-1201A is in conflict between the datasheet and the line list
  • open blocking comment: The test pressure basis cites the line list, which states 26 barg, while the datasheet for P-1201A states 24 barg. The derived test pressure cannot be stated until this is resolved.
  • open blocking comment: Acceptance criteria state a 2 hour hold. Appendix D requires the hold to be witnessed; the procedure does not say who witnesses it or what they sign.
ZRF-ITP-0008Inspection and Test Plan - Condensate Export Piping SupportsN. OkonkwoA. RahmanR. Haddad
Nothing

Approvals recorded

Recorded approvals
DeliverableByAttestation
ZRF-ITP-0003R. Haddad
Checked by A. Rahman, reviewed by S. Lindqvist, no blocking findings outstanding.
ZRF-PEP-0001R. Haddad
Reviewed by the Company representative; Appendix F gap recorded and accepted.

Approve

Recorded verbatim against you. Say what was checked, and by whom.

What is refused

  • The author approving their own deliverable
  • Approval while an input gap is open
  • Approval while a blocking comment is open
  • Approval by somebody without the approver capability
  • An attestation that says nothing
  • Approval with no independent check behind it

Administering is not authority

Approval needs the capability, granted by name. Why