Document conflicts and exceptions
Everything EDS refused to resolve on its own, each needing one decision from a person.
Demonstration project - no figure here describes a real facilityChanges are not saved
Open exceptions
10
Blocking
10
Supersession candidates
1
Unreadable
1
Conflicting attributes
2
| Type | Document | Detail | Severityascending |
|---|---|---|---|
| Drawn, not in any register | ZRF-PID-1202 p.1 | P-1299X: A tag drawn on ZRF-PID-1202 that appears in no register. Expected finding: a not-in-register finding that blocks anything the tag would state. | Blocking |
| Supersession | ZRF-PID-1202 p.1 | HV-1203: A valve shown on ZRF-PID-1202 Rev A and removed at Rev B, so it exists only on a superseded revision. Expected finding: a superseded-only finding that blocks use. | Blocking |
| Missing sheet | ZRF-PID-1202 p.1 | ZRF-PID-1299: A continuation callout on ZRF-PID-1202 naming a sheet the project does not hold. Expected finding: a missing-reference finding; the continuation cannot be followed. | Blocking |
| Ambiguous reading | ZRF-PID-1101 p.1 | PT-1201 / PT-120I: The scanned P&ID carries PT-120I, a misreading-shaped variant of PT-1201 that the grammar accepts. Expected finding: a near-duplicate finding that blocks use of both readings. | Blocking |
| Boundary disagreement | ZRF-PID-3101 p.1 | HV-3101 system placement: The commissioning breakdown puts HV-3101 in SYS-31-01 and the drawn boundary on ZRF-PID-3101 puts it outside. Expected finding: a placement conflict in which nothing is chosen and the drawn boundary is never promoted. | Blocking |
| Conflicting attribute | ZRF-DS-P-1201A p.1 | P-1201A and 12-CD-1201-150-A1A design pressure: The pump datasheet rates P-1201A at 24 barg and the line list rates its discharge line 12-CD-1201-150-A1A at 26 barg. Both cannot be the design intent for one connected system, and which is right decides the hydrotest pressure. Expected finding: a safety-critical attribute conflict that presents no value and blocks approval. | Blocking |
| Conflicting attribute | ZRF-REG-LL-001 p.1 | P-1201A and 12-CD-1201-150-A1A design pressure: The pump datasheet rates P-1201A at 24 barg and the line list rates its discharge line 12-CD-1201-150-A1A at 26 barg. Both cannot be the design intent for one connected system, and which is right decides the hydrotest pressure. Expected finding: a safety-critical attribute conflict that presents no value and blocks approval. | Blocking |
| Boundary disagreement | ZRF-REG-VR-001 p.1 | HV-3101 system placement: The commissioning breakdown puts HV-3101 in SYS-31-01 and the drawn boundary on ZRF-PID-3101 puts it outside. Expected finding: a placement conflict in which nothing is chosen and the drawn boundary is never promoted. | Blocking |
| Missing sheet | ZRF-CTR-APX-F | Declared by the contract and not received. No file is held. Seeded unreceived appendix: the page count is the count the contract states, not a count of pages anybody has read. | Blocking |
| Unreadable | ZRF-PID-9001 p.1 | A scan too faint to read. Processing refuses it and states why; nothing is extracted. | Blocking |
Showing 1 to 10 of 10 exceptions
Page 1 of 1
Blocking exceptions stop approval
A deliverable that depends on an unresolved blocking exception can still be drafted, but it cannot be approved for issue.
Resolve one
Nothing is resolved by preference
EDS does not choose the higher-confidence value, the more recent document or the more complete record. Every row here is a decision it declined to make, and each resolution stores who made it, when, and on what basis.